What
is Regional Equity?
In many of the nation's metropolitan regions,
the outer edges enjoy growth and prosperity, while central cities
and declining suburbs experience overall population loss and
intensifying concentrated poverty. These disparities are more
than geographic - they are racially and economically distributed,
with areas populated by communities of color impacted most adversely.
Though divided by highways, subdivisions, and municipal borders,
all parts of the region share a common responsibility and a common
fate. Keeping a region healthy requires coordination on the issues
of housing, employment, transportation, education, and other
key racial and economic equity concerns. In these ways, every
resident of the region can gain fair access to crucial opportunities.
Two interrelated forces are largely responsible for regional
disparities:
- suburban sprawl
and its corollary, metropolitan fragmentation (the division
of the metropolitan region into separate, exclusive municipal
districts); and
- racialized concentrated poverty (meaning high neighborhood or city poverty that
disproportionately impacts communities of color).
- Sprawl and Fragmentation. Suburban sprawl and its counterpart, metropolitan
fragmentation, siphon regional resources, jobs, educational opportunity,
and tax bases from central cities and economically depressed
suburbs, and transfer them to developing suburbs through the
process of middle-class suburbanization and exclusionary land
use practices. The borders between the city and the region's
numerous suburban jurisdictions become barriers that allow developing
suburbs to amass resources and tax base while walling off greater
social need in the central city and inner-ring suburbs. They
also greatly limit access to opportunities that emerge in these
suburbs, such as jobs, for residents of the region's center.
- Concentrated Poverty. With their isolation from growing regional opportunities,
central cities and declining inner-ring suburbs witness intensifying
concentrated poverty and exacerbation of the social problems
associated with it, including failing schools, a declining tax
base, high rates of unemployment, and increasing crime rates.
As these problems worsen, more middle-class and white residents
flee to distant jurisdictions, intensifying disparities by taking
with them much-needed resources.
Those who are racially and economically
segregated in the region have little access to the prosperity
abundant in the suburbs. Municipal boundaries and fragmentation
have effectively "closed the door" to these opportunities,
ensuring that all resources stay cordoned off in opportunity-rich
jurisdictions.
Regional equity has three basic premises:
- Regional health depends on the health
of all sectors of the region;
- Central cities and declining suburbs cannot
confront the problems of racialized concentrated poverty independently,
that is, without a regional focus; and
- A regional approach to equity issues must
support rather than undermine the political power, social cohesion,
and sense of place of all residents of the region, but particularly
those communities who have long been denied effective voice as
a result of regional forces.
Achieving Regional Equity
No single initiative will alleviate the
disparities that continue to grow within our metropolitan regions.
A comprehensive set of initiatives is required to address the
complex and cumulative nature of racial and economic segregation
that is at the heart of regional disparities:
1. Economic Development Initiatives:
The economic vitality of a region depends
on the well-being of its central city and declining suburbs.
If these areas are faring well, the entire region will benefit.
- The focus should be on minimizing wasteful
competition within the region and strengthening the regional
economy by attracting new investment into the area. The entire
region loses when a business relocates within the region because
it has been heavily subsidized by a competing jurisdiction. Resource-poor
central cities and inner-ring suburbs often cannot provide these
subsidies.
- Redevelopment and revitalization efforts
within central cities and their struggling inner-ring suburbs
should focus on drawing residents and businesses back to regain
the population and resources they have lost to suburbanization.
However, protections should be put in place to ensure that gentrification,
meaning the displacement of lower income residents of these revitalizing
areas, often families of color, does not occur (e.g., via rent
control and other housing preservation devices).
2. Housing Initiatives:
Affordable housing crises plague metropolitan
areas across the country. Housing that is affordable is most
often located in the central cities or inner-ring suburbs, far
from developing suburbs where the region's opportunities are
growing most rapidly. Affordable housing is often entirely unavailable
in growing suburbs because exclusionary zoning, such as large
lot size requirements, makes it difficult to build housing at
a cost that low-income families can afford.
Locating affordable housing throughout
a region is desirable because it allows low-income residents
access to the opportunities such as jobs, better schools, and
a solid tax base that supports social services, that have relocated
in the suburbs. Taking a regional equity approach also means
protecting housing in revitalizing areas of the central city
and inner-ring suburbs, in order to prevent gentrification and
the displacement of low-income residents and residents of color
from areas characterized by emerging opportunities.
- Fair share housing remedies remove some of the barriers to creating affordable
housing in the suburbs. Fair share housing affirmatively requires
that the entire region support its fair share of the region's
need for low-income housing, thus taking some of the burden off
the central cities and ideally breaking down economic and racial
segregation.
- Mixed-income development in high-poverty central cities and suburbs is a
complimentary strategy to equalize the disparities among the
central city and its more prosperous suburbs. By attracting the
middle-class back to the city, resources may equalize and the
health of the region could improve. Again, appropriate safeguards
against gentrification and displacement must be created, or the
development of mixed-income housing could force low-income families
to other areas of economic isolation.
3. Education Initiatives:
Educational success is closely linked with
residential location. Students attending schools in areas with
high rates of poverty tend to fare less well than their counterparts
in more economically stable schools. Given the intersection of
race and poverty, the students attending high poverty schools
tend to be students of color. Interdistrict desegregation is
one solution to alleviating inequities among suburban and central
city schools.
4. Employment Initiatives:
Closely linked to economic development,
employment initiatives should address the growing spatial mismatch
between the location of jobs and where workers reside. Businesses
should be encouraged to enter into partnerships with communities
to foster training, education, and employment practices that
redress the racial and economic disparities across the region.
5. Transportation Initiatives:
Transportation initiatives should address
the spatial mismatch of jobs and workers.
Transportation equity strategies ensure that transit projects
focus on alleviating economic
and racial segregation, not simply making it easier for white,
middle-class commuters to get to the city.
6. Tax-Base Sharing:
Tax-base sharing is a strategy to create
equity across the region by allowing high tax base areas within
the region to share these resources with the rest of the region,
operating on the understanding that regional prosperity requires
an equitable balance of resources and need.
7. Anti-Sprawl Initiatives:
Anti-sprawl initiatives that redirect growth
back toward the central city and inner-ring
suburbs will promote regional equity. Containing haphazard development
will prevent further isolation of low-income people of color
from the opportunity structures of the region and can promote
revitalization and redevelopment at the regional core. For these
resources to truly serve the goal of regional equity, policies
must work to ensure that low-income families and people of color
are able to maintain housing in revitalizing areas and not be
displaced to other areas of concentrated poverty.
8. Regional Governance:
Some form of regional governance may be
necessary to effectively implement these regionally-focused initiatives.
The regional equity initiatives outlined here rely on the transcendence
of the fragmented jurisdictional system responsible for the parsing-out
of regional resources and need. Moreover, a growing body of work
has confirmed that the metropolitan region has become the economic
unit of global competitiveness. |